Are these 2 hairstyles the same thing?

I’m getting a haircut today and I’m deciding between 2 pictures to show to the cutter/hairstylist. But I’m wondering if these are just the same thing with different color, length and with differently combed bangs. If they’re not the same, then which one would look better for someone with a round face and a large nose? I have borderline dark brown/black hair.

Picture One:

http://hairstyles.thehairstyler.com/hairstyle_views/front_view_images/436/original/2909_Ashton-Kutcher-d_copy_2.jpg

Picture Two:

http://img713.imageshack.us/img713/5820/ashtonkutchermay012008.jpg

Further details:
Italian descent. Brown eyes. Age 16. No facial hair.
Okay, thanks, but which one do you think would fit me better?
(Round face, large nose)
@Dona
well obviously the color is different…